Why Bikepackers Avoid Using Panniers: An In-Depth Analysis

Bikepacking is a popular outdoor activity that involves riding a mountain bike off-road and carrying gear on the bike or in backpacks. However, one thing that you won’t see on a bikepacker’s bike is panniers. Panniers are typically used for touring or commuting, but why don’t bikepackers use them? In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind this and examine the advantages and disadvantages of using panniers for bikepacking. So, whether you’re a seasoned bikepacker or just starting out, read on to discover why panniers may not be the best choice for your next adventure.

Understanding Bikepacking

What is bikepacking?

Bikepacking is a form of cycling that involves riding off-road, typically on rough terrain and over long distances. Unlike traditional touring, which typically involves a support vehicle and luggage, bikepacking is self-supported, meaning that all gear and supplies must be carried on the bike.

Bikepacking trips often involve camping in the wilderness, and riders may need to carry a variety of equipment, including tent, sleeping bag, stove, food, and water. Because of the nature of the terrain and the distances involved, bikepackers need to be able to carry their gear efficiently and with minimal weight.

Panniers, which are saddlebags that attach to the frame or fork of a bicycle, are a common way to carry gear on a bike. However, bikepackers often avoid using panniers for a number of reasons, which will be explored in the following sections.

Why is it different from traditional cycling?

Bikepacking is a form of cycling that has gained popularity in recent years, particularly among adventure seekers and outdoor enthusiasts. While traditional cycling is focused on covering long distances as efficiently as possible, bikepacking is a more versatile and exploratory approach to cycling. Here are some key reasons why bikepacking is different from traditional cycling:

• Destination-based: Bikepacking trips often have a specific destination in mind, whether it’s a remote campsite, a scenic vista, or a particular trailhead. This is in contrast to traditional cycling, which is often focused on covering a set distance within a certain time frame.
• Gear carriage: Bikepackers typically carry a greater amount of gear than traditional cyclists, as they need to be self-sufficient for several days at a time. This includes camping equipment, food, water, and repair tools, among other items. This means that the type of gear carriage system used is crucial for bikepackers.
• Terrain versatility: Bikepacking routes often cover a variety of terrain types, including gravel, dirt, and singletrack trails. This requires a different set of skills and equipment than traditional cycling, which is usually focused on paved roads.
• Exploration and discovery: Bikepacking is often seen as a way to explore new places and discover hidden gems that are off the beaten path. This sense of discovery is a key part of the experience, and is not necessarily a focus of traditional cycling.
• Community and connection: Bikepacking has a strong sense of community, with many riders sharing their experiences and routes online. This creates a sense of connection and shared purpose among bikepackers, which is not always present in traditional cycling.

Overall, bikepacking is a unique form of cycling that emphasizes exploration, self-sufficiency, and community. It is different from traditional cycling in many ways, and the gear carriage system used is a crucial part of the experience.

The Problem with Panniers

Why panniers are not suitable for bikepacking

Bikepacking is a type of cycling that involves carrying gear on a bicycle while exploring off-road trails and dirt roads. While traditional touring cyclists often use panniers to carry their gear, bikepackers prefer to use different types of bags and packs that are better suited to the demands of off-road cycling.

One of the main reasons why bikepackers avoid using panniers is that they can be cumbersome and unstable on rough terrain. Panniers are designed for smooth pavement and can shift around or even fall off when the terrain gets rough. This can make it difficult to maintain control of the bike and can also damage the panniers or the bike itself.

Another issue with panniers is that they can interfere with the bike’s handling. Panniers are typically larger and heavier than other types of bags, which can affect the bike’s balance and make it more difficult to maneuver. This can be particularly problematic in tight or technical terrain, where the ability to quickly change direction is crucial.

Additionally, panniers can be bulky and take up a lot of space on the bike. This can limit the bike’s carrying capacity and make it difficult to fit all the gear needed for an extended trip. Bikepackers often prefer bags that are more compact and can be easily attached and removed from the bike as needed.

Finally, panniers can be heavy and add extra weight to the bike. This can make it more difficult to pedal and can also affect the bike’s overall performance. Bikepackers often prefer lighter and more streamlined bags that won’t slow them down or make the bike harder to handle.

Overall, while panniers may be suitable for traditional touring cyclists who primarily ride on paved roads, they are not ideal for bikepacking. Bikepackers prefer bags and packs that are more compact, lightweight, and better suited to the demands of off-road cycling.

How do panniers affect bike handling and balance?

One of the primary reasons why bikepackers avoid using panniers is that they can negatively impact the handling and balance of a bicycle. Panniers are typically made of heavy materials such as metal or canvas, which can add significant weight to the bike. This additional weight can affect the handling and balance of the bike, making it more difficult to control, particularly at high speeds or when carrying heavy loads.

Additionally, panniers are typically attached to the sides of the bike, which can alter the bike’s center of gravity. This can make it more difficult to maintain balance, particularly when the bike is loaded with heavy gear. As a result, bikepackers often prefer to use alternative carrying methods, such as backpacks or frame bags, which are designed to be more balanced and stable.

Moreover, panniers can also interfere with the bike’s suspension, particularly if they are not properly installed. This can lead to reduced shock absorption and a rougher ride, which can be particularly uncomfortable on long trips. As such, many bikepackers opt for alternative carrying methods that do not interfere with the bike’s suspension system.

In conclusion, the way panniers affect bike handling and balance is a crucial factor for bikepackers when choosing the best carrying method for their gear. While panniers can be a convenient and practical option for some cyclists, bikepackers often prefer alternative methods that prioritize stability, balance, and handling.

The weight and size limitations of panniers

Panniers are an excellent way to carry gear while cycling, but they come with their own set of limitations. One of the main problems that bikepackers face when using panniers is the weight and size limitations.

Weight limitations

Panniers are designed to carry a certain amount of weight, and exceeding this limit can cause problems. When a pannier is overloaded, it can become difficult to handle the bike, and the wheels may become misaligned. This can lead to accidents and damage to the bike.

In addition, an overloaded pannier can affect the rider’s balance, making it harder to maintain control of the bike. This can be particularly dangerous when riding off-road or on rough terrain.

Size limitations

Panniers also have size limitations, which can make it difficult to carry larger items. This can be particularly problematic for bikepackers who need to carry bulky gear, such as tent poles or trekking poles.

Furthermore, the size of the panniers can affect the rider’s handling of the bike. Larger panniers can make it harder to maneuver the bike, particularly when riding in tight spaces or over obstacles.

In conclusion, the weight and size limitations of panniers can pose significant challenges for bikepackers. To overcome these limitations, many bikepackers turn to other methods of carrying gear, such as using frame bags or backpacks. These alternative methods allow bikepackers to carry more weight and larger items, making them ideal for extended trips into the wilderness.

Alternatives to Panniers

Frame bags

One of the primary reasons why bikepackers tend to avoid using panniers is due to the fact that they can often be bulky and cumbersome, especially when it comes to off-road riding. In contrast, frame bags offer a more streamlined and low-profile solution for carrying gear, which can be particularly useful for those who prefer a more minimalist approach to bikepacking.

Benefits of Frame Bags

There are several benefits to using frame bags over panniers, including:

1. Low Profile: Unlike panniers, frame bags are attached directly to the frame of the bike, which means they sit much lower and closer to the ground. This not only reduces wind resistance, but also makes it easier to maneuver the bike in tight spaces or off-road terrain.
2. Increased Maneuverability: With frame bags, there is no need to worry about the added weight and bulk of panniers, which can make it easier to navigate through narrow trails or technical terrain. Additionally, the low profile of frame bags makes it easier to lean the bike without the risk of catching a pannier on a branch or rock.
3. Easy Access: Because frame bags are typically located on the top tube or down tube of the bike, they are easily accessible at all times. This makes it simple to quickly grab or remove items without having to unpack the entire bag.
4. Weight Distribution: Since frame bags are attached directly to the frame, they offer a more balanced and stable way to carry gear. This can be particularly useful for longer rides or when carrying heavier loads.

Frame Bag Design and Fit

When it comes to frame bags, it’s important to choose a design that is well-suited to the specific bike and riding style. Different frame bags are designed for different types of bikes and riding conditions, so it’s important to choose a bag that fits well and offers the necessary features for the intended use.

For example, some frame bags are designed to be more compact and lightweight, making them ideal for carrying essentials for shorter rides or when weight is a concern. Other frame bags are designed to be larger and more robust, making them better suited for longer trips or carrying heavier loads.

When choosing a frame bag, it’s important to consider the specific needs and preferences of the bikepacker. Some factors to consider include the type of bike, the intended terrain, the length of the trip, and the amount of gear that will be carried. By taking these factors into account, bikepackers can choose a frame bag that offers the perfect balance of storage capacity, weight, and performance.

Handlebar bags

Bikepackers often prefer handlebar bags over panniers for several reasons. These bags are designed to be attached to the handlebars of a bicycle, providing a convenient and secure way to carry gear. Here are some reasons why handlebar bags are a popular alternative to panniers among bikepackers:

Weight Distribution

One of the main advantages of handlebar bags is their ability to distribute weight evenly around the bicycle’s handlebars. This design helps to reduce the strain on the bike’s frame and prevents the bike from feeling unbalanced. In contrast, panniers are often heavy and can cause the bike to feel unstable, especially when they are fully loaded.

Accessibility

Handlebar bags are easy to access, allowing bikepackers to quickly grab or retrieve items without having to take the bags off the bike. This is particularly useful when cycling through rough terrain or in areas where the bike may be difficult to maneuver. Additionally, handlebar bags are typically smaller and more compact than panniers, making them easier to store when not in use.

Customization

Handlebar bags come in a variety of sizes and shapes, allowing bikepackers to customize their gear to their specific needs. This means that bikepackers can choose the exact amount of storage they need for their trip, rather than having to settle for a pre-determined size offered by panniers. Additionally, handlebar bags can be easily removed from the bike and stowed away when not in use, providing a convenient way to transport gear between different modes of transportation.

Aerodynamics

Another advantage of handlebar bags is their aerodynamic design. Panniers can catch the wind and create drag, making it harder for the bike to move through the air. Handlebar bags, on the other hand, are typically more streamlined and can reduce wind resistance, making it easier for the bike to move through the air. This is particularly important for long-distance bikepacking trips, where every bit of energy savings counts.

Overall, handlebar bags offer a number of advantages over panniers, making them a popular choice among bikepackers. Whether it’s their weight distribution, accessibility, customization, or aerodynamics, handlebar bags provide a convenient and practical way to carry gear on a bike.

Saddle bags

Saddle bags are a popular alternative to panniers among bikepackers for several reasons. Firstly, they are lightweight and easy to attach and remove from the bike, making them a convenient option for those who prefer not to use panniers. Secondly, they are typically made of durable materials that can withstand the elements, such as waterproof fabrics and rugged zippers. This makes them a suitable choice for those who plan to travel long distances off-road or in inclement weather.

Moreover, saddle bags offer a more streamlined and aerodynamic design compared to panniers, which can help reduce wind resistance and improve the overall performance of the bike. This is particularly important for long-distance cyclists who prioritize speed and efficiency.

However, it is worth noting that saddle bags may not be as practical for those who need to carry a large amount of gear, as they tend to have smaller capacity than panniers. Additionally, they may not provide as much protection for fragile items, such as electronic devices, as panniers with more cushioning and suspension systems.

Overall, saddle bags are a popular alternative to panniers among bikepackers due to their lightweight, durable, and aerodynamic design. However, their smaller capacity and lack of protection for fragile items may make them less suitable for some riders.

Why these alternatives are preferred by bikepackers

One of the main reasons why bikepackers prefer alternatives to panniers is that they offer greater freedom and flexibility. Panniers can be restrictive and may not allow for easy access to gear, whereas alternatives like saddlebags, frame bags, and backpacks provide easier access and more options for packing gear. Additionally, bikepackers may prefer these alternatives because they can be more comfortable, allowing for a more enjoyable riding experience.

The Benefits of Ditching Panniers

Improved bike handling and maneuverability

Bikepackers often prefer to ditch panniers in favor of other carrying solutions for a number of reasons, one of which is the improved bike handling and maneuverability that results from reducing the weight and bulk of their gear. Here’s a closer look at why this is the case:

• Weight reduction: When a bike is loaded down with heavy panniers, it can become more difficult to handle, particularly when navigating tight corners or steep inclines. By using lighter, more streamlined carrying solutions like frame bags and handlebar rolls, bikepackers can significantly reduce the weight of their gear, making their bikes much easier to handle.
• Improved aerodynamics: The sleek, low-profile design of frame bags and handlebar rolls means that they create less wind resistance than panniers, making it easier to maintain speed and control on longer rides. This is particularly important for bikepackers who spend extended periods of time on the road, as the reduced drag can make a significant difference in overall ride comfort and efficiency.
• Enhanced agility: With fewer obstacles hanging off the sides of their bikes, bikepackers are able to maneuver more nimbly through tight spaces and technical terrain. This can be especially helpful when riding off-road, where obstacles and hazards are more common and can require quick and nimble bike handling.
• Easier loading and unloading: Without the need to clip and unclip panniers, bikepackers can quickly and easily load and unload their gear, making it simpler to pack up and hit the road for an adventure. This can save valuable time and effort, particularly when embarking on multi-day rides or expeditions.

Overall, by ditching panniers in favor of lighter, more streamlined carrying solutions, bikepackers can enjoy improved bike handling and maneuverability, making their rides more enjoyable and efficient.

Reduced weight and increased speed

One of the primary reasons why bikepackers avoid using panniers is that they can significantly increase the weight of their bikes, which in turn can slow down their progress. By ditching panniers, bikepackers can reduce the overall weight of their bikes, which allows them to travel faster and more efficiently.

Reducing the weight of a bike can have a significant impact on its performance, particularly when cycling over long distances or on rough terrain. Every additional pound that a bike carries adds resistance to its movement, which can make it harder to pedal and increase fatigue over time. By removing panniers and using alternative carrying methods, bikepackers can significantly reduce the weight of their bikes, which can help them to ride further and faster.

Another advantage of reducing the weight of a bike is that it can also improve its maneuverability and handling. When a bike is carrying a heavy load, it can become more difficult to steer and balance, which can be particularly challenging when cycling downhill or over rough terrain. By reducing the weight of their bikes, bikepackers can improve their control and stability, which can help them to navigate tricky terrain with greater ease and confidence.

In addition to reducing the weight of their bikes, bikepackers can also increase their speed by using alternative carrying methods that allow them to carry their gear more efficiently. For example, using a frame bag or a seat pack can provide a more streamlined and aerodynamic shape, which can reduce wind resistance and improve speed. By using these methods, bikepackers can travel more quickly and efficiently, which can help them to cover greater distances in less time.

Overall, reducing the weight of a bike and using alternative carrying methods can provide significant benefits for bikepackers, particularly when cycling over long distances or on rough terrain. By ditching panniers, bikepackers can improve their speed, maneuverability, and control, which can help them to explore the great outdoors with greater ease and efficiency.

Enhanced versatility and adaptability

One of the primary reasons why bikepackers opt against using panniers is the enhanced versatility and adaptability that they offer. By removing the constraints of traditional panniers, bikepackers can explore a wider range of terrains and tackle more challenging routes. Here are some of the specific benefits that bikepackers experience when they ditch their panniers:

• Greater maneuverability: Without the weight and bulk of panniers, bikepackers can easily navigate through tight trails, narrow paths, and technical terrain. This allows them to access remote areas and reach locations that would be inaccessible with traditional panniers.
• Improved stability: The removal of weight from the bike’s frame and the addition of bags that are better integrated into the bike’s design can significantly improve the bike’s stability. This is particularly important for bikepackers who ride in rugged terrain or off-road, as it reduces the risk of tipping over or losing control.
• Increased speed: Bikepackers who use frames bags and other alternative storage solutions can cover more ground in less time. This is because they are not limited by the weight and size of their panniers, which can slow them down on steep climbs or during long distances.
• Enhanced stealth: When bikepackers use frames bags and other lightweight storage solutions, they are less conspicuous to wildlife and other trail users. This allows them to get closer to wildlife and experience a greater sense of immersion in the natural environment.

Overall, the enhanced versatility and adaptability that bikepackers experience when they ditch their panniers allow them to push the boundaries of what is possible on a bike. Whether they are exploring remote wilderness areas or tackling technical terrain, bikepackers who use alternative storage solutions can travel further, faster, and more comfortably than those who rely on traditional panniers.

How ditching panniers enhances the overall bikepacking experience

Ditching panniers while bikepacking can lead to a more liberating and enjoyable experience in several ways. By freeing oneself from the constraints of traditional panniers, bikepackers can discover newfound freedom and flexibility, enabling them to fully immerse themselves in the natural environment. Here are some reasons why ditching panniers can enhance the overall bikepacking experience:

• Increased mobility: Panniers can limit the range of motion while cycling, making it difficult to navigate tight trails or rocky terrain. Without panniers, bikepackers can move more freely and easily navigate through diverse landscapes, opening up a world of possibilities for exploration.
• Reduced weight: Carrying panniers can add significant weight to the bike, which can be especially challenging during long rides or off-road adventures. By ditching panniers, bikepackers can shave off precious pounds, making it easier to carry other essential gear and supplies, such as lightweight backpacks or frame bags.
• Greater simplicity: Panniers often require careful packing and organization, which can be time-consuming and stressful. By forgoing panniers, bikepackers can simplify their gear setup, allowing them to focus more on the journey itself, rather than worrying about the logistics of carrying their belongings.
• Improved aerodynamics: Bikepackers who choose to ditch panniers can benefit from improved aerodynamics, as they can ride in a more streamlined position, reducing wind resistance and increasing speed. This is particularly relevant for long-distance riders or those participating in competitive events.
• Enhanced self-reliance: By relying on fewer external gear systems, bikepackers can develop a greater sense of self-reliance and autonomy. This can foster a deeper connection with the natural environment and promote a more meaningful experience overall.
• Customizable gear options: Without the constraints of panniers, bikepackers have the freedom to choose from a wider range of gear options, such as frame bags, handlebar bags, and seat bags. This allows for greater flexibility in customizing their gear setup to suit specific needs or preferences.
• Greater environmental awareness: Bikepackers who opt for lighter and more sustainable gear options, such as reusable water bottles or biodegradable packaging, can contribute to a more environmentally conscious approach to adventure travel. This can help to minimize the impact on the natural environment and promote a more responsible and sustainable way of exploring the great outdoors.

Overall, ditching panniers while bikepacking can offer a unique and rewarding experience, providing greater freedom, flexibility, and self-reliance, while also enhancing the overall enjoyment of the journey.

Recap of the reasons why bikepackers avoid using panniers

• Weight distribution: Panniers can disrupt the balance of a bike, affecting its handling and making it more difficult to maneuver.
• Comfort: Carrying panniers can cause pressure points and discomfort, especially over long distances.
• Speed: Bikepackers often prioritize speed and efficiency, and panniers can add unnecessary weight and resistance to the bike.
• Accessibility: Panniers can limit the ability to access gear and supplies, requiring more time to pack and unpack.
• Flexibility: Bikepacking routes often involve rugged terrain and unexpected changes, making it essential to have a flexible gear system that can adapt to different conditions.
• Style: Bikepackers may prefer the aesthetic of a minimalist setup and the sense of freedom it provides.
• Environmental impact: Panniers can contribute to litter and waste in the outdoors, which bikepackers may wish to avoid.
• Cost: Panniers can be expensive, and bikepackers may prefer to invest in other gear or upgrades for their bikes.

The importance of understanding the specific needs of bikepacking

Understanding the specific needs of bikepacking is crucial for bikepackers to make informed decisions about the gear they use. Bikepacking is a unique form of cycling that involves carrying gear on a bike, often for extended periods of time and in remote areas. Unlike traditional touring or commuting, bikepacking often involves more technical terrain, steeper grades, and longer distances, which means that the gear must be chosen with care.

One of the main reasons why bikepackers avoid using panniers is that they can add unnecessary weight and complexity to the bike. Panniers are designed for traditional touring, where the emphasis is on carrying a lot of gear and supplies for extended periods of time. In contrast, bikepacking is often more focused on efficiency and minimalism, with the goal of carrying only what is necessary for the specific trip.

In addition, panniers can make it difficult to maneuver the bike in technical terrain, such as rough trails or rocky descents. This can make it more challenging to navigate obstacles and maintain control of the bike, which can be particularly dangerous in remote areas where help may not be readily available.

Furthermore, panniers can limit the bike’s ability to perform well in different conditions. For example, if the bike is equipped with panniers, it may not perform as well in sand or mud, which can make it more difficult to navigate challenging terrain.

Overall, understanding the specific needs of bikepacking is crucial for choosing the right gear. Bikepackers must consider the type of terrain they will be riding, the distance they will be covering, and the type of gear they need to carry. By carefully selecting gear that is designed for bikepacking, bikepackers can ensure that they have the right tools for the job, without unnecessary weight or complexity.

Final thoughts and recommendations for bikepackers looking to explore new gear options.

For bikepackers who are looking to explore new gear options, it’s important to consider the benefits of ditching panniers. Here are some final thoughts and recommendations to keep in mind:

• Experiment with different carrying methods: Instead of relying solely on panniers, try using backpacks, saddle bags, or handlebar bags to carry your gear. Each method has its own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s worth exploring different options to find what works best for you.
• Consider the terrain: The type of terrain you’ll be riding on can affect your gear choices. For example, if you’re planning on riding on rough, off-road trails, you may want to avoid carrying heavy panniers that could get caught on branches or rocks. On the other hand, if you’re sticking to smooth, paved roads, panniers may be a more practical option.
• Prioritize lightweight gear: One of the main advantages of ditching panniers is the ability to carry less weight. Make sure to prioritize lightweight gear that won’t weigh you down, but still provides the necessary functionality for your trip.
• Think about your personal style: Finally, consider your personal style and preferences when choosing your gear. Some bikepackers prefer the sleek, minimalist look of a bike with just a handlebar bag or backpack, while others may prefer the more traditional look of a bike with panniers. Choose gear that makes you feel comfortable and confident on your bike.

FAQs

1. Why don’t bikepackers use panniers?

Bikepackers typically avoid using panniers because they can add weight and complexity to the bike, making it harder to maneuver and slowing down progress. Additionally, panniers can be bulky and take up space on the bike, which can make it difficult to carry all the necessary gear. Bikepackers prefer to use lightweight, compact, and streamlined systems that allow them to carry their gear in a more efficient and comfortable manner.

2. What are some alternatives to panniers for bikepacking?

There are several alternatives to panniers that bikepackers use, such as frame bags, handlebar bags, seat bags, and backpacks. These options offer more flexibility and allow bikepackers to carry their gear in a way that is more tailored to their specific needs. Frame bags attach to the frame of the bike and provide a low-profile, secure, and weather-resistant way to carry gear. Handlebar bags and seat bags offer additional storage options that can be easily accessed while riding. Backpacks are also popular among bikepackers, as they allow for greater freedom of movement and can be used both on and off the bike.

3. What are the benefits of using frame bags for bikepacking?

Frame bags offer several benefits for bikepackers, including a low-profile design that does not interfere with the bike’s handling, secure storage that protects gear from theft and damage, and weather-resistant materials that keep gear dry in all conditions. Additionally, frame bags can be customized to fit the specific needs of the bikepacker, allowing them to carry only the gear they need for their specific trip. This can help to reduce weight and increase efficiency, making frame bags a popular choice among bikepackers.

4. How do bikepackers choose the right gear for their trips?

Bikepackers choose the right gear for their trips based on several factors, including the length and difficulty of the trip, the climate and terrain, and their own personal preferences and needs. They carefully consider the weight, size, and functionality of each piece of gear, and choose items that are both practical and durable. Bikepackers also tend to prioritize gear that is easy to access and use while riding, as this can help to improve efficiency and comfort during the trip.

5. What are some tips for carrying gear on a bike for bikepacking?

There are several tips for carrying gear on a bike for bikepacking, including using a balance system to distribute weight evenly across the bike, keeping gear organized and easily accessible, and using weather-resistant materials to protect gear from the elements. Bikepackers should also consider the size and shape of their gear, and choose items that can be easily secured to the bike without interfering with its handling. Finally, it’s important to test and adjust the gear setup before setting out on the trip, to ensure that it is comfortable and functional for the specific conditions and terrain.