Why Don’t People Use Panniers for Bikepacking?

Bikepacking is an exciting way to explore the great outdoors, and it has become increasingly popular in recent years. But have you ever wondered why people don’t use panniers for bikepacking? It’s a question that has puzzled many cyclists, and the answer is not as simple as you might think.

In this article, we will delve into the world of bikepacking and panniers, exploring the pros and cons of each and why one might be preferred over the other. From the weight and practicality of panniers to the freedom and flexibility of bikepacking bags, we will examine the factors that influence this choice and why some cyclists choose to leave their panniers at home.

So, if you’re curious about the world of bikepacking and want to know why panniers aren’t always the go-to choice for adventurous cyclists, read on!

A Lack of Knowledge About Panniers

What Are Panniers?

Panniers are a type of luggage designed to be attached to the sides of a bicycle. They are typically made of durable materials such as canvas or nylon, and have a waterproof lining to protect the contents from the elements. Panniers are often used for bike touring or bikepacking, as they provide a convenient way to carry gear and supplies while on a bike ride.

Panniers have a long history, dating back to the 19th century when they were first used by cyclists in Europe. They were originally made of leather and were popular among touring cyclists who needed a way to carry their gear. Today, panniers are available in a variety of sizes and styles, with options for both men and women.

There are several types of panniers available, including:

• Hard panniers: These panniers are made of a hard shell and are typically more durable than soft panniers. They are also more waterproof and are a good option for wet weather conditions.
• Soft panniers: These panniers are made of a soft material, such as canvas or nylon, and are more flexible than hard panniers. They are also generally lighter and more compact than hard panniers.
• Top-loader panniers: These panniers attach to the top of the bicycle frame and are designed to be used with a rack. They are a good option for carrying heavier loads.
• Front-loader panniers: These panniers attach to the front of the bicycle and are designed to be used with a rack. They are a good option for carrying gear that needs to be easily accessible.

Benefits of Using Panniers for Bikepacking

Using panniers for bikepacking offers several benefits that can enhance the overall experience and comfort of the ride. Some of these benefits include:

• Increased carrying capacity: Panniers are designed to provide additional storage space for gear, clothing, and other essentials. They offer a spacious and secure compartment that can accommodate more items than a traditional backpack or saddlebag. This increased carrying capacity allows bikepackers to pack more gear and equipment, which can be particularly useful on longer trips or multi-day expeditions.
• Better weight distribution: Panniers are designed to distribute weight evenly around the bike, which helps to maintain balance and stability. By distributing the weight more evenly, panniers reduce the strain on the rider’s back and shoulders, making the ride more comfortable. This is particularly important for those who are not used to carrying heavy loads on their bikes, as it can help prevent fatigue and discomfort.
• Protection from the elements: Panniers provide a protective barrier between the gear and the elements. They are made from durable materials that can protect gear from rain, wind, and other adverse weather conditions. This is particularly important for those who are riding in remote or challenging environments, where the weather can be unpredictable and extreme.
• Easy access to gear: Panniers are designed to be easily accessible, allowing riders to quickly and easily access their gear during the ride. This is particularly important for those who need to access their gear frequently, such as when stopping for breaks or setting up camp. With panniers, riders can quickly and easily access their gear without having to remove their backpack or other equipment.

Common Misconceptions About Panniers

• Panniers are only for touring
  One common misconception about panniers is that they are only suitable for long-distance touring. This belief likely stems from the fact that panniers were originally designed for touring cyclists who needed to carry heavy loads for extended periods. However, this could not be further from the truth. Panniers are equally suitable for bikepacking, as they provide a convenient and secure way to carry gear for any type of cycling trip.
• Panniers are too heavy
  Another misconception about panniers is that they are too heavy for bikepacking. While it is true that some panniers can be quite heavy, this is not always the case. Many modern panniers are designed to be lightweight and durable, making them an ideal choice for bikepacking. Additionally, the weight of panniers can be easily offset by the gear they carry, making them a practical choice for bikepackers who need to carry a significant amount of equipment.
• Panniers are not versatile enough
  Some people believe that panniers are not versatile enough for bikepacking. This misconception likely stems from the fact that panniers are often associated with traditional touring bikes, which may not be well-suited for off-road riding. However, this could not be further from the truth. Many panniers are designed to be versatile and can be easily attached to a variety of bicycles, including mountain bikes and gravel bikes. Additionally, panniers can be easily removed when not in use, making them a highly versatile choice for bikepackers who need to adapt to changing conditions.

Limited Availability of Panniers for Bikepacking

The Traditional Pannier

When it comes to traditional panniers, they are typically designed for regular bicycles and are not specifically made for bikepacking. This means that they may not be as durable or versatile as other types of bags.

• Aluminum or steel frame: The frame of a traditional pannier is typically made of aluminum or steel, which can make it heavy and less flexible than other materials.
• Waterproof fabric or tarpaulin: Traditional panniers often use waterproof fabric or tarpaulin to protect the contents inside. However, this material can be heavy and not as breathable as other materials.
• Roll-top closure: The roll-top closure is a common feature of traditional panniers, which allows for a tight seal to keep contents dry. However, this closure can be difficult to operate while on the move and may not be as secure as other closure methods.
• External attachment points: Traditional panniers may have external attachment points, such as bungee cords or straps, which can be used to secure additional gear. However, these attachment points may not be as versatile or adjustable as other attachment methods.

Overall, traditional panniers may not be the best option for bikepacking due to their lack of specific design features for this type of activity. While they may be suitable for shorter, less intense trips, they may not be able to handle the demands of longer, more challenging bikepacking adventures.

Alternative Options for Bikepacking

One of the primary reasons why panniers are not as popular among bikepackers is due to their limited availability. While panniers are widely used for traditional touring and commuting, they are not as well-suited for bikepacking due to their bulk and weight. As a result, many bikepackers turn to alternative options that offer more versatility and convenience.

Frame bags are a popular alternative to panniers for bikepacking. These bags are designed to attach directly to the frame of the bike, providing a more streamlined and low-profile option. They are typically made of lightweight materials like Cordura or similar fabrics, making them ideal for bikepacking where weight and packability are critical factors. Frame bags come in a variety of sizes and shapes, from small top tube bags to larger seat tube bags, providing ample storage space for gear and equipment.

Handlebar bags are another popular option for bikepacking. These bags attach to the handlebars of the bike and are designed to provide quick and easy access to essential items like food, water, and navigation tools. They are often made of lightweight materials like TPU or similar fabrics, and come in a range of sizes and shapes, from small bar-end bags to larger, more substantial bags that can hold a significant amount of gear. Handlebar bags are particularly useful for short and quick bikepacking trips where convenience and ease of access are essential.

Seat bags are another popular alternative to panniers for bikepacking. These bags attach to the seatpost of the bike and provide a convenient and accessible storage option for items like a camera, spare clothes, or a lightweight sleeping bag. Seat bags are typically made of lightweight materials like Cordura or similar fabrics, and come in a range of sizes and shapes, from small saddle bags to larger, more substantial bags that can hold a significant amount of gear. They are ideal for bikepacking trips where the focus is on exploring remote and rugged terrain, as they provide quick and easy access to essential items without the need for frequent stops.

Why Bikepackers Choose Alternative Options

One of the primary reasons why bikepackers choose alternative options to panniers is due to their weight. Panniers are typically heavier than other options, which can be a significant factor for bikepackers who are looking to minimize the weight of their gear. This is especially true for those who are participating in long-distance bikepacking races or rides, where every ounce counts.

Another reason why bikepackers choose alternative options is due to their compatibility with different bike types. Panniers are not always designed to fit all types of bikes, which can make them an impractical option for some bikepackers. This is especially true for those who are riding bikes with unusual frames or suspension systems, which may not be compatible with traditional panniers.

Finally, bikepackers may choose alternative options due to the flexibility they offer in terms of gear placement. Panniers can be restrictive in terms of where gear can be placed on the bike, which can make it difficult to achieve the optimal balance and weight distribution. Alternative options, such as frame bags or seat packs, offer more flexibility in terms of where gear can be placed, which can be especially important for bikepackers who are looking to optimize their bike’s performance and handling.

Panniers vs. Alternative Options for Bikepacking

Comparison of Features

One of the main reasons why people do not use panniers for bikepacking is due to the lack of compatibility with different bike types. Panniers are designed to fit on specific types of bikes, such as touring bikes or mountain bikes, and may not fit on other types of bikes. This can make it difficult for people who have bikes that are not compatible with panniers to use them for bikepacking.

Another issue with panniers is their weight. While they are designed to be durable and able to handle the demands of bikepacking, they can also be quite heavy. This can make them difficult to carry on longer rides or when carrying a heavy load. Additionally, panniers can be quite expensive, which can be a barrier for some people who are looking to get into bikepacking.

Durability is another area where panniers may fall short for some bikepackers. While they are designed to be rugged and able to handle the demands of bikepacking, they may not be able to withstand the rough terrain and harsh conditions that some bikepackers encounter. This can make them less suitable for certain types of rides or for people who are looking to go on longer, more challenging trips.

Water resistance is another feature that may be lacking in panniers for some bikepackers. While they are designed to be waterproof, they may not be able to withstand the wet and muddy conditions that some bikepackers encounter. This can make them less suitable for certain types of rides or for people who are looking to go on longer, more challenging trips.

Finally, accessibility is another area where panniers may fall short for some bikepackers. While they are designed to be easy to use and accessible, they may not be suitable for people with certain disabilities or mobility issues. This can make them less suitable for some people who are looking to get into bikepacking.

Pros and Cons of Each Option

Panniers

Panniers are a popular choice for bikepacking as they offer a convenient and accessible way to carry gear. They are typically made of waterproof materials and can be easily attached and removed from the bike. One of the main advantages of using panniers is that they provide a large amount of storage space, allowing the rider to pack all of their gear and equipment in one place. Additionally, panniers are designed to distribute weight evenly across the bike, making it easier to handle and reducing the risk of tipping over.

However, there are also some disadvantages to using panniers. One of the main issues is that they can be bulky and difficult to maneuver, especially in tight spaces or on rough terrain. This can make it difficult to navigate through tight trails or narrow paths, and can also make it challenging to access gear while on the move. Additionally, panniers can be heavy and add a significant amount of weight to the bike, which can make it more difficult to handle and reduce the overall performance of the bike.

Frame bags

Frame bags are another popular option for bikepacking, as they offer a more streamlined and compact way to carry gear. They are typically attached to the frame of the bike, rather than the wheels, and can be easily accessed while on the move. One of the main advantages of using frame bags is that they are more compact and lightweight than panniers, making it easier to handle the bike and reducing the overall weight. Additionally, frame bags are designed to be more flexible and adaptable, allowing the rider to customize the amount of storage space they need based on the specific trip.

However, there are also some disadvantages to using frame bags. One of the main issues is that they can be less secure than panniers, as they are not attached to the wheels and can potentially move around while on the move. Additionally, frame bags can be more difficult to access while on the move, as they are typically located on the frame of the bike and can be harder to reach.

Handlebar bags

Handlebar bags are a popular option for bikepacking, as they offer a convenient and accessible way to carry gear. They are typically attached to the handlebars of the bike and can be easily accessed while on the move. One of the main advantages of using handlebar bags is that they provide a convenient and accessible way to carry gear, as they are located close to the rider and can be easily reached while on the move. Additionally, handlebar bags are typically lightweight and compact, making it easier to handle the bike and reducing the overall weight.

However, there are also some disadvantages to using handlebar bags. One of the main issues is that they can be less secure than panniers or frame bags, as they are not attached to the wheels or the frame of the bike and can potentially move around while on the move. Additionally, handlebar bags can be more difficult to access while on the move, as they are typically located on the handlebars and can be harder to reach.

Seat bags

Seat bags are a popular option for bikepacking, as they offer a convenient and accessible way to carry gear. They are typically attached to the seat post of the bike and can be easily accessed while on the move. One of the main advantages of using seat bags is that they provide a convenient and accessible way to carry gear, as they are located close to the rider and can be easily reached while on the move. Additionally, seat bags are typically lightweight and compact, making it easier to handle the bike and reducing the overall weight.

However, there are also some disadvantages to using seat bags. One of the main issues is that they can be less secure than panniers or frame bags, as they are not attached to the wheels or the frame of the bike and can potentially move around while on the move. Additionally, seat bags can be more difficult to access while on the move, as they are typically located on the seat post and can be harder to reach.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Gear

Personal Preferences

One of the most significant factors to consider when choosing gear for bikepacking is personal preferences. Different individuals have varying tastes and styles, and this plays a crucial role in determining the type of gear they prefer. Some people may prefer the traditional approach of using panniers, while others may prefer backpacks or other types of luggage. The choice of gear should be based on personal comfort and preference.

Trip Length and Duration

Another essential factor to consider when choosing gear for bikepacking is the length and duration of the trip. For short trips, a small backpack or a daypack may be sufficient. However, for longer trips, a larger and more durable backpack or panniers may be required to accommodate more gear. It is important to choose gear that is suitable for the length and duration of the trip to ensure that it is comfortable and practical.

Terrain and Weather Conditions

The terrain and weather conditions of the trip should also be considered when choosing gear for bikepacking. For example, if the trip involves off-road cycling, it may be necessary to choose gear that is more durable and protective. If the trip is in an area with harsh weather conditions, it may be necessary to choose gear that is waterproof and suitable for wet conditions. It is important to choose gear that is suitable for the terrain and weather conditions of the trip to ensure that it is practical and functional.

Type of Bike and Setup

Finally, the type of bike and setup should also be considered when choosing gear for bikepacking. Different types of bikes require different types of gear. For example, a mountain bike may require more durable and protective gear than a road bike. Additionally, the setup of the bike, such as the number of water bottle holders or the type of rack, may affect the choice of gear. It is important to choose gear that is suitable for the type of bike and setup to ensure that it is practical and functional.

FAQs

1. What are panniers?

Panniers are a type of luggage designed to be attached to the front or rear of a bicycle. They are typically made of waterproof materials and have a capacity of 10-30 liters.

2. Why don’t people use panniers for bikepacking?

There are several reasons why people don’t use panniers for bikepacking. One reason is that panniers can be heavy and can add extra weight to the bicycle, making it harder to pedal. Additionally, panniers can be bulky and can make it difficult to maneuver the bicycle in tight spaces. Finally, panniers are not as versatile as other types of bikepacking gear, such as frame bags and backpacks, which can be attached to the bicycle or worn on the person.

3. What are some alternatives to using panniers for bikepacking?

There are several alternatives to using panniers for bikepacking. One option is to use frame bags, which are designed to attach to the frame of the bicycle and can be more streamlined and lightweight than panniers. Another option is to use a backpack, which can be worn on the person and can provide more versatility than panniers. Additionally, some people prefer to use a combination of frame bags and backpacks to distribute their gear more evenly.

4. Are panniers suitable for any type of bikepacking trip?

Panniers may be suitable for some types of bikepacking trips, but they are not ideal for all types of terrain or conditions. For example, panniers may be too bulky for technical off-road trails or for trips that require a lot of climbing. Additionally, panniers may not be the best choice for trips that require a lot of portaging, as they can be difficult to carry when not attached to the bicycle.

5. Can panniers be used with electric bikes?

Yes, panniers can be used with electric bikes. However, it is important to choose panniers that are designed to fit electric bikes, as they may have different requirements than traditional bicycles. Additionally, it is important to consider the weight and size of the panniers, as they can affect the range and performance of the electric bike.

10 Items Not To Bring Bikepacking